What the New U.S. Foreign Policy Should Look Like
By Daniel G. Jennings
Lately, I’ve added my voice to the chorus calling for a new US foreign policy that reflects the realities of today’s very dangerous world. Therefore I suppose I must offer my ideas on US foreign policy and the global situation.
Such a policy must take into account two obvious facts that will become clearer as the years progress. Fact one: US military power is limited and is likely to shrink in the years ahead meaning that we won’t be able to keep all of our commitments let alone take on new ones that will be forced upon us by circumstance. Fact Two: for the first time since World War I there are at least three other powers out there whose military and economic resources rival and could one day surpass America’s: China, India and Russia. No, I don’t count Europe as a major power, the European is a bad joke, it’s military resources are limited and in terminal decline.
The situation is ripe for disaster if the US pursues a unilateral go it alone policy of being the world’s policeman it’ll either find itself in conflict with one or more of these powers. Or worse we we’ll find ourselves in a situation where we’ll have to go begging to Beijing, New Delhi and Moscow for help.
Sadly enough such a situation is quite likely because the Indians, the Russians and especially the Chinese haven’t been pulling their weight as major powers. Instead of serious involvement in international crises all they’ve done is dispatch a few units on UN peacekeeping duty, a cruel farce that does nothing to promote peace or protect innocent people from thugs and terrorists.
My proposal is this, the US should start a new great power club: the Big Four or Four policemen as FDR proposed during World War II. The Big Four Powers, US, China, India and Russia (okay maybe Big Five or Big Six we should probably let Britain and Japan join if just for old times sake) would work together to police the world. That is their military forces would work together to respond to things like terrorism, natural disasters, rogue states and containing conflicts. The Big Four could pool their resources for things like international development, foreign, aid, exploitation of resources, scientific research, education, space exploration, etc. For example they could build a joint international space station and a joint moon base and launch a joint manned Mars Mission. Their militaries could conduct joint training maneuvers and their military personnel could attend schools in each others’ nations. An example of such cooperation might be that in some future conflict India and China which have lots of manpower could provide the ground troops while America provides the Naval forces and logistical support and Russia air units, tanks and intelligence.
Such an arrangement is certainly doable, there is little or no hostility between these four major powers. Three of them, America, India and Russia are democratic. Yes China is still a dictatorship governed by a group that calls itself the Communist Party, yet the Chinese Communist Party no longer believes in Communism. The Chinese leadership wants economic growth and development, it has more in common with nationalist dictators like Francisco Franco, Augusto Pinochet and Chiang Kai Sek (all of whom proved to be reliable US allies and all of whose regimes were succeeded by successful democracies) than Mao or Castro. I might add that the US won the Cold War by successfully partnering with such authoritarian dictators to the disgust of human rights advocates and the left.
A Big Four (or Big Five or Six Alliance, Britain will undoubtedly be leaving the European Union soon and looking for new friends, especially if France melts down) Alliance would certainly be in the mutual interest of all four nations. All these Countries want to keep the international economy ticking, they want to keep the trade lanes open, the oil flowing and the stock market going up. They have mutual interests like securing oilfields, policing the seas, suppressing terrorism, controlling the excesses of rogue states, containing disease and maintaining stability around the globe.
The United States should take the lead in forming the Big Four by inviting the Prime Minister of India, President Putin of Russia and the President of China perhaps Tony Blair should also be invited to Washington for a summit conference to lay down the ground work of such an alliance. This summit should become a yearly or bi yearly event and there should be a regular discussion say a weekly teleconference between all four leaders. This should be followed by formal meetings between the cabinet ministers and military commands of all four nations and joint maneuvers.
There could be other symbolic gestures, the Chinese astronauts (takonauts) should be invited to visit the International Space Station, train with NASA and ride on the space shuttle. NASA should ask if an astronaut could take a ride in the Chinese space capsule perhaps to visit the international space station.
One early move the Big Four could announce that all four nations are not going to participate in the European farce known as the International Court of Justice in the Hague. Perhaps they should establish their own International Court to try war criminals, terrorists and the like in Beijing or Washington. This new International Court unlike the fraud in Europe would be able to met out the death penalty (Russia, China and India, like America, have and regularly administer the death penalty in other words the USA has more in common with these nations than Europe), the only punishment monsters like Saddam Hussein are really afraid of.
Such a move would pull the rug out from under the tired old powers of Europe and let them know where they really stand in the world. It would also establish the Big Four as the dominant alliance in the world and let the world’s bad guys know that we’re serious about shutting them down.
Obviously, such a stratagem will involve a sea change in American thinking on both the right and the left. We’ll have to accept two nonwhite, non Christian powers (India and China) as equals, we’ll have to dump our Eurocentric view of the world and turn our backs upon our traditional allies in Europe and possibly Japan. Liberals will have to abandon their fantasies about international law and the United Nations for a more realistic view of the world. Traditional conservatives will have to consign isolationism to the dustbin of history where it belongs. Neoconservatives will have to give up their grandiose vision of remaking the world in our image and put the Blueprint for the New American Century in the shredder.
Most importantly Americans will have to realize that we are not the center of the world anymore. Our position is or soon will be more akin to first among equals than dominant super power.
Establishing a Big Four type alliance would promote real international cooperation and peace in a realistic way that would avoid conflict. It would also do far more to secure America’s and the world’s future than any plan to “fix” the United Nations or waste our tax dollars on Strategic Missile Defense.